Widor's Fifth Symphony (for organ) is one of the most popular organ works. And especially the dazzling Toccata, which rivals popularitys Toccata and fugue in d. It is a pity that Widor's other organ symphonies (10 in all) have remained in the shadow of the Fifth. Especially the later symphonies (no. 5-10) are just as impressive. Widor's melodies may appear superficial at first hearing, as if the
… sentimental influences of salon music are never far away. However, the design is monumental, and the control of the (French Romantic) organ is masterful. The famous Cavaillé-Coll organ of the abbey church in Rouen was used for this recording, an instrument very often chosen for this type of repertoire. The organ was put into use by Widor himself on April 17, 1890 with his Symphony gothique (in fact his ninth organ symphony). The designation 'gothique' was a reference to the architectural style of this medieval abbey church. Especially the lyrical Andante sostenuto from this symphony is fairytale-like. This part is also written perfectly for the instrument, with a cleverly used double pedal (both feet playing at the same time in a very wide position). Christiaan Schmitt's playing is elegant and logical, qualities that this music cannot do without. The more thoughtful moments could sometimes have been taken wider, but it is certainly beautiful. (HJ)more
